The Arbitrary 1984 Cutoff, Marriage Out Of Community Of Property.

In late 2023, the Constitutional Court significantly reshaped the legal landscape surrounding asset division upon the dissolution of marriage in South Africa. This change emerged from the landmark cases of EB v ER and Others; KG v Minister of Home Affairs and Others [2023] ZACC 32, which struck down the long-standing November 1, 1984 date restriction that limited who could seek a redistribution order under the Divorce Act. The implications of this ruling continue to ripple through legislative reform, with the General (Family) Laws Amendment Bill introduced in 2025 aiming to embed these judicial changes into permanent law by 2026.Traditionally, couples married out of community of property without accrual maintained completely separate financial estates. Under this marital system, no automatic entitlement existed for one spouse to share in the wealth accumulated by the other during the marriage, whether in cases of divorce or death. This framework disproportionately affected spouses, often women, who contributed non-monetarily through domestic work or child-rearing, roles undervalued in the absence of financial recognition.The Constitutional Court’s intervention addressed a critical flaw: the arbitrary 1984 cutoff, which denied many spouses recourse to redistribution simply because of when their marriage commenced. The Court recognized that the purported “choice” of a marriage system was often undermined by unequal bargaining power, and thus perpetuated unfair outcomes. By removing this temporal barrier, the Court empowered judges with discretion to order asset redistribution for any marriage out of community of property without accrual, irrespective of its start date. This also secures protections for surviving spouses, who no longer risk facing destitution due to outdated legal gaps.This evolution marks a significant advancement toward fairness in family law, acknowledging that managing a household and raising children are indispensable contributions to marital wealth. As legislative processes unfold to formalize these changes, the law moves closer to rectifying historical inequities and better reflecting the realities of modern marital partnerships.

Related Practice Areas: Asset Division

If you have questions about your specific situation, contact Nick Elliot for a confidential consultation.